Know about Want to help us give voice to the voiceless, speak out against injustice? Or just celebrate our voices? Join us!

Bin laden
Image via Wikipedia

This post first appeared on the Dawn Blog

So how do you react to the news of the world’s most wanted man being caught in a compound less than two kilometres away from the country’s finest military academy? Shocked? Embarrassed? Baffled?  Difficult to say since most of us are still trying to make sense out of it all.

In the aftermath of one of the most dramatic manhunts in recent history, statements coming in from the Foreign Office left many questions unanswered.  Both the military and the government appeared to be struggling with possible ways to deal with the situation. The initial statements suggested an intelligence failure from Pakistan’s end while the US announced a successful operation carried out by the CIA along with the US Navy SEALs.

Unsurprisingly, not many fell for the explanation. The fact that the Pakistani military – who have been fighting the war on terror for the past decade – were unaware of the world’s most dangerous man living right under their nose could only suggest two things: incompetence or malice.  Neither of which are in anyway favorable to the country’s image or future. Fortunately, it became increasingly evident that the military was probably trying to do some damage control in an attempt to neutralise possible backlash. Even if we were to go by the statement that the Pakistani military did not take part in the operation itself, the fact that the operation was a collective effort is undeniable.  There is no way a 40-minute gun battle went unnoticed just round the corner from the Kakul Military Academy.

The extent of the role played by the Pakistani military, whether limited to intelligence reporting only, might not be clear for now. But even that does not absolve us from the many questions that have been raised – how did Osama bin Laden get here?  How long has he been living in Abbottabad? When was his presence first reported or were the authorities aware of his presence all along? If so, why did it take so long to execute the operation, and the list is endless. There is in fact, a lot to explain about what happened between Tora Bora and Abbottabad.

Obama, in his address,while announcing the death of bin Laden said that the operation was being planned for many months. Some news sources claim that first intelligence reports date back to April 2010. Dawn reports that Osama might have been killed by own guard rather than the US Navy SEALs. Questions have also been raised about his burial in the sea. At this point in time, when the story is still developing and we are yet to see DNA reports and photographic evidence of Osama’s death, these questions shall have to wait.

(The Christian Science Monitor answers some questions regarding the operation.)

These incidents and statements do not exist in a vacuum; the implications and repercussions of bin Laden’s capture and killing, are a grave reality. The initial statements that the military had no information on the operation led to a frenzy of queries in mainstream media. Television channels, specifically Urdu news channels resorted to calling bin Ladin a ‘shaheed,’ while a leading investigative journalist declared that bin Laden was in fact, not a terrorist. The analysis on bin Laden’s killing became more of a debate on the country’s sovereignty and whether foreign troops should be allowed to enter our territory and conduct operations. Some went as far as suggesting that bin Laden’s death meant an end to al Qaeda and therefore an end to the war on terror – all the while naively forgetting that al Qaeda was never a one-man army to begin with and that killing bin Laden would be more of an incentive for terror than an end to the war.

But that’s just our side of the story; the bigger picture puts Pakistan in a rather compromising state. As the world celebrates Osama’s death as a victory there’s little to celebrate for us. While we cannot deny the fact that Osama’s death is a milestone for the war on terror it is also inevitably the beginning of a new era of violence, terror and destruction in Pakistan. The Tehrik-e-Taliban Pakistan has already announced its’ retaliation.

Lest the world forgets: “As many as 12,580 people were killed across Pakistan in 2010 alone, as per (HRCP)  report. 1,159 people were killed in 67 suicide attacks whereas US drones strikes were responsible for 957 extra-legal killings.”

As the facts about the operation that killed bin Laden unravel, we must brace ourselves to stand united against violence. No redemption here; not yet.

Enhanced by Zemanta

16 thoughts on “Beyond bin Laden

  1. Till the time comes when our people start using their own brains rather than replicating what’s reflected in mainstream media, let’s keep expecting Pakistan to go further down the drains!!

  2. You don’t react. Maybe think a little and move on, doing whatever it is that you started off with, doing that day. That’s probably the least an individual can do.

  3. Sana,
    Osama was a “bahana”. if you believe in Uncle SAM story then i wish you all the best.
    I have been watching this mama drama since i heard the first few minutes after it happened.
    Next target is “Nuclear Facilities in pakistan”. After wachting CIA media in USA and reading blogs of people like you i have no reason to doubt that Pakistan is the next “War Theater”. Its so stupid that CIA create OSAMA then kills it and blame at Pakistan and people like you start lecturing pak about civilized world. Please also elaborate on the suffering of ordinary paksitanis on the hand of USA+TTP. TTP was founded by CIA after 9/11. if educated people like you believe in everything what CIA Media says then i can only look toward sky and start praying. common sense ,rationalism seems no where. Common people like us getting hurt from TTP thugs and Cow Boys Rambos. May God mercy be upon us.

    1. Imitiaz, as much as I would want this to be one huge set up the reality is fairly different. When our own authorities have accepted the facts of the operation there is really no point in denying it. In order to move forward or comment on a situation being politically correct is important. If CIA concocted it, than ISI agreeing means they are in this too? What do you reckon?

  4. You said it 12,580 people get kill in Pakistan
    Who cares?
    Not the BBC,, tv5monde

    Even worst, most Pakistani don’t care when women get gang rape and paraded naked in public
    And the court of law set the rapists free

  5. Well written sana as always, but I’d just like to add, are we even sure that the person killed was in fact OBL? No pictures have surfaced, no video. Could it be just an attempt to further tarnish the image of the Pakistan Military and the ISI? Or maybe just a drama to initiate an exit strategy from Afghanistan?

    1. Thanks Qasim, I understand your point about pictures or proof from the raid itself. But if this was an ISI concocted drama to ‘tarnish the ISI’ why did the ISI play along? why have they endorsed the statement of bin Laden’s presence in that compound? more importantly what good will ‘tarnishing the image’ get you when the ‘promised aid’ is only bound to increase after this?
      Exit strategy from Afghanistan? Really? How is the Afghan war a success if they’ve been bombing the wrong country for a decade?

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )


Connecting to %s